- Primary Subject: Paul Anthony Kelly as DCU Batman
- Key Update: Rising star Paul Anthony Kelly has become the top fan-favorite candidate for the DCU’s Batman.
- Status: Unconfirmed
- Last Verified: February 17, 2026
- Quick Answer: No official casting has occurred. While rumors link Paul Anthony Kelly to the role, James Gunn maintains that Batman casting begins after the script is finished.
There have been rumors for a while that Love Story star Paul Anthony Kelly is set to play the DCU's Batman. But is there any truth to that speculation?
For the last few years, fans have been eagerly anticipating which actor DC Studios will cast to play the DCU's version of the Caped Crusader. While some are still hoping Robert Pattinson's version will be integrated into the DCU, several actors have also been rumored for the role, and a new name has emerged.
Is Paul Anthony Kelly Playing the DCU's Batman? Rumor Explained
Deuxmoi, an outlet that is notorious for sharing alleged blind-item scoops, recently posted that they've heard Paul Anthony Kelly is being considered for a role in the DCU.
Fans have speculated that the "certain role" might be related to Batman, a role that has still not been cast in the DCU, and a type of character that fits Kelly's appearance.
Kelly is a newcomer actor who is currently on the rise, thanks to his starring role as John F. Kennedy, Jr. in the new limited series Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette.
Since the rumor emerged, fans online have expressed support for the possibility of Kelly getting cast as the DCU's Batman, and there is a consensus among them that he is a great choice for the role.
Some of Kelly's recent social media posts have also been flooded with comments from fans who are clamoring for him to get cast in the role. It remains to be seen whether he is interested in taking on the iconic role, but he seems to have the momentum at the moment.
So far, DC Studios co-chairman James Gunn has not commented on the rumors surrounding Kelly's potential casting in the DCU.
What's Next in the DCU Franchise?
The next DCU movie is Supergirl, which is set to release in theaters on June 26. It is the second theatrical project in the franchise, following last year's Superman.
In the upcoming film, when an unexpected and ruthless adversary strikes too close to home, Kara Zor-El, aka Supergirl, reluctantly joins forces with an unlikely companion on an epic, interstellar journey of vengeance and justice.
They are also working on other upcoming films, such as Clayface and Man of Tomorrow. On the television side, they are working on Lanterns, which will release on HBO later this year.
Keep it locked on Epicstream, your go-to site for film, TV, and celebrity coverage!